People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great service! The home made pizza is outstanding. Great burgers as well. Clean! ”
“ Always consistent food and quality food, and of course their Pizza ”
“ What a fantastic hideaway! Gave the owners a ride back from the draft in GreenBay and they welcomed me in and I tried some of their food. I had a Baccon Cheeseburger and jalapeno poppers. The burger was cooked to perfection almost smashburger like. Now I'm a big fan of jalapeno poppers and good poppers are hard to find. Well I assure you they found them. They were perfect! Not steaming hot on the inside where you end up burning the roof of your mouth. They tasted so good! Will definitely be returning. ”
“ We went out to get a bite to eat. To my surprise, that was the BEST burger n curds around. It was Cooked perfectly, mouthwatering taste with the sense of home cooked with love. We will definitely be back. And the waitress was such a doll, very friendly and polite. ”
“ Amazing pub food at unbelievable prices. 7 to 10 1/2 pound burgers with super fresh other ingredients, generous side dishes. Very clean. A hidden gem. ”
“ Love the pizza! Take-out makes for a quick, easy dinner on busy nights. ”
“ Best steak sandwich and pizza!! ”
“ Great small town bar. Great food. Great service and bartenders. What's not to like! ”
About
Bullpen Forestville
Welcome to Bullpen Forestville, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Forestville, Wisconsin. Located at 213 W Main St #9691, this cozy spot has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a reputation for exceptional service and a warm atmosphere, Bullpen Forestville stands out in the realm of casual dining.
Customers rave about the homemade pizza that has captured the hearts of many, including the delightful pizza connoisseur Linda Ruth. Her praise for the outstanding quality and consistency of both the pizza and burgers reflects the restaurant’s commitment to using fresh ingredients. Each item on the menu is crafted with care, ensuring that every bite is a testament to the establishment's culinary passion.
One standout dish that has garnered multiple accolades is the Baccon Cheeseburger. This burger has made waves, particularly through the eyes of Dave Egan, who described it as "cooked to perfection." The mouthwatering flavor mirrors a well-executed smash burger, while the jalapeno poppers have rightfully earned their reputation for being exactly what poppers should be—not too hot, yet delectable.
For those seeking a homey touch in their dining experience, Bullpen Forestville does not disappoint. Customer Sarah Morsette notes the burger and cheese curds as being the best around, emphasizing the perfect cook and a "sense of home cooked with love." It’s clear that each staff member is dedicated to maintaining a friendly and inviting atmosphere, creating a lovely dining experience that keeps patrons returning.
With unbelievable prices and generous portions, it’s easy to see why Jennie LaVaque and others deem this spot as the place for amazing pub food. The menu centers around simplicity yet never sacrifices quality. Whether you’re digging into a burger, sharing a pizza, or indulging in sides, every dish speaks volumes about the care taken to serve only the best.
Bullpen Forestville is a café where the community gathers, laughter fills the air, and delicious food tells stories. So, if you find yourself in Forestville, make sure to stop by for an experience that combines taste, quality, and heart. Don’t forget to call them at +1 920-856-6199 for any inquiries!
Book a table